Cosentino Winery was founded by self-taught winemaker Mitch Cosentino in 1980. Mitch is the first person we have met born in Gustine, California (a small town south of Modesto). He discovered an interest in wine during college, prior to a career with wine he earned a degree in Broadcast Communications. Finding the job market in this field somewhat challenging in the mid to late 1970s he turned to wine. He signed on with a regional distribution company as their most junior salesman (Stanislaus Distributing Co). Within a year and a half his talents for sales was evident; he soon started managing this small company.
NOTE: in mid 2024 the Cosentino Winery and property sold to Brion Wise. Wise did not purchase the Cosentino brand or its existing inventory. Until late 2024, Cosentino was owned by Vintage Wine Estates, which declared bankruptcy in 2024. After the subsequent sale of all of Vintage Wine Estate’s assets, the brand Cosentino was purchased by Foley Family Estates, the current owner. Their is no longer a public tasting room for the Cosentino wines, however they continue to be produced and sold online.
Part of Mitch’s work at the distribution company involved wine maker dinners – where he met some of the icons in the industry – Myron Nightingale and Ed Spragia (both Beringer Winery veterans) and John Parducci (Mendocino County wine pioneer). Mitch considers all of these individuals as role models and they are the ones who helped encourage him to become a winemaker – recognizing his excellent sense of smell and taste.
Mitch has been making wines commercially since 1980; that year at age 30, he began Crystal Valley Cellars on Hosmer Avenue in Modesto producing wines under Crystal Cellars and Cosentino Select. Later the operations were moved to 16750 E Highway 88 in Lockeford. Early in his career, Mitch was already producing award winning wines. In 1986 Cosentino won Best of Class and a gold medal at the Los Angeles County Fair for several of his wines bottled under Crystal Valley Cellars. In the early years his grapes were source from Central Valley vineyards, but later he began sourcing from vineyards closer to the coast.
In the mid to late 1970s he also taught a wine appreciation class at a community college in Modesto. He is a self-taught winemaker; before he started Crystal Valley Cellars, he made home wine.
Moving to Napa Valley in 1990 he has since been responsible for creating, designing and building nine wineries in the Napa Valley and Lodi. Mitch was also the early winemaker for Napa brands such as Gemstone and Hoopes. Mitch oversaw the construction of the winery and hospitality center which opened in 1990.
Select Wines
As of the time of this review Cosentino produces a variety of different wines including from both Napa Valley (bottled under the Cosentino label) and Lodi and state of Washington (including wines bottled under the Cigar label featuring old vine Zinfandel and a more recent addition, bourbon barrel aged Cabernet Sauvignon). At one point the Legends wine was created through a partnership with former basketball star, Larry Bird.
Whites
The 2023 Cosentino Winery, The Novelist Meritage Napa Valley is a blend of 53% Sauvignon Blanc, 47% Sémillon; this wine was aged for 8 months in a stainless steel tank. It is pale to medium straw in color; Dancing tango and simultaneously singing soprano, the bouquet is filled with vibrancy and freshness two years post vintage. Its scent are of not fully ripe pineapple, plenty of citrus influence including kaffir life, lemon zest, lemon grass, guava, orange blossom and freshly mowed grass. While its herbal varietal influences are present, they are never overtly green or grassy. The palate shows riper than the bouquet; its flavors include honeycomb, golden delicious apples, white nectarine, pineapple guava, lychee and honeysuckle, a flavor that reminds us of pulling out the stamen and pistol from a honeysuckle and enjoying the resulting small drop of ‘nectar’. The fruit is ripe with a light sweet character, including a lingering note of vanilla and sweet anise. And there is a creamy fleshiness and light viscosity from the contribution of the Sémillon. The acidity is bright and balanced. Easy drinking. And drinks quite well by itself. The inaugural vintage of this wine was in 2002.
The 2017 Cosentino Winery, The Novelist Meritage Napa Valley. This white wine blend was created as an accompanying wine for their red blend, the Poet. Much as a Novelist creates their own work of art through the written word for others to enjoy, the winemaker creates his or her own masterpiece through blending. This vintage is 88% Sauvignon Blanc and 12% Sémillon. Initially and as, it continues to breath, the bouquet offers sweet floral aromatics including jasmine, honeysuckle and a lemon/orange peel zest nuance. The palate is highly balanced from the entry through the finish; this wine tastes like ripe grapefruit and citrus (tangerine). It finishes with a pleasing crispness, but no tartness or greenness sometimes associated with Sauvignon Blanc.
The 2016 Cosentino Chardonnay, Napa Valley is sourced primarily from Mitsuko’s Vineyard (the vineyard was named after Clos Pegase Winery founder Jan Shrem’s wife at the time, Mitsuko) in the Carneros District. This wine went through a small amount of secondary fermentation. Presents a variety of aromas including sweet dessert spices, toasted oak, ripe pear and melon. Flavorful but not heavy on the palate – very clean from start to finish with just a hint of butter. Drinks well by itself. Nicely balanced between a California style chardonnay (oak/buttery) and a more Burgundian style.
Mitsuko’s Vineyard
Reds
The 2022 Cosentino Winery THE Zin, Lodi is 99% Zinfandel and 0.5% each of Petite Sirah and Petit Verdot. This wine was aged for 13 months in a combination of both French and American oak barrels. The first vintage of Cosentino Zinfandel was in 1990. This wine is medium ruby; the bouquet smells ripe but not to the point of being liqueur like. Its aromas include raspberry jam, cherry cola, red plums and some threads of baking spices including cardamom and clove. Fully ripe, with a union of both red and darker fruits, this wine tastes like raspberry, boysenberry, cherry pie, pomegranate, cherry cola, root beer, sarsaparilla with finishing assorted spices of cardamom, cloves and a light skosh of white pepper and toasted oak. And a note of vanilla. Tastes slightly sweet. The tannins are fully ripe, resolved and rounded and are integrated seamlessly into the ripely fruited finish. We would not argue with you if you want to describe this wine’s texture as creamy.
The 2021 Cosentino Winery Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley is deep ruby and opaque; sweetly fruited and very much a ripe aromatic expression of the variety, this wine smells like blackberry jam, boysenberry pie, dark cherry, baked plums, blueberry compote, and dark mulberry with accompanying secondary scents from the barrel including dark chocolate, cocoa powder, roasting coffee beans and baking spices including cinnamon and nutmeg. As generous on the palate as the bouquet, there are flavors of dark cherry, black plums, dark raspberry, mulberry, black licorice and dark chocolate. Finishes lightly sweet with pillowy and well-tumbled rounded tannins. Their presence lingers gently and lightly with a subtle but persistent chalky character in tandem with the ripe fruit. Its listed ABV is 14.5% but we suspect in reality its higher.
The 2017 Cosentino Pinot Noir Reserve, Napa Valley spent 18 months in French oak barrels; like their Chardonnay, the grapes were also sourced from Mitsuko’s Vineyard in the Carneros District. Pretty aromatics. Spice + fruit makes for a savory showing. Forward in its fruit presentation (raspberry and red cherry) complemented by notes of white pepper, mocha and a subtle hint of cedar. Very flavorful with good acidity shows red cherry and red currant with bright acidity. Lingers with darker spices and a kiss of tannin.
Mitch enjoys drinking and making wine from Italian varieties; during his ownership he produced wines from Sangiovese and Nebbiolo (although Cosentino no longer makes wines from these varieties). Their flagship red blend, The Poet was the first designated Meritage wine in the country (blended with traditional red varieties grown in Bordeaux).
Cosentino used to produce several dessert wines including a late harvest Viognier and a botrytis Sémillon. Today they produce a single non-vintage red dessert wine. In the past, Cosentino has also donated a percentage of some of their Cabernet Sauvignon wine sales to the V Foundation’s Cancer Fund Research.
A real treat during one of our tastings many years ago was a beautiful Cosentino 1997 Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon; this wine was rare in that it was already aged for many years in the bottle at the time of our tasting. The characteristic browning of the edges in the glass indicated this wine had had some aging behind it; it was very full bodied with fruit flavors that had integrated well at this age – showing plum and cherry with notes of smokiness and tobacco lingering on the finish.
And as of our last update to this review, Cosentino used to produce a Zinfandel from the Harris Blue Ridge Vineyard, Napa County’s highest vineyard with the uppermost vines topping out at 2,742 feet in a remote part of the county on the slopes of Mt. Vaca next to the Solano County line. For reference, other high vineyards in Napa Valley are on Howell Mountain (Black Sears & also Candlestick Vineyard), Atlas Peak (Kongsgaard) and Mt. Veeder (Merryvale), but certainly none as high as this one.
Harris Blue Ridge Vineyard
Their wines have been served at special functions including a White House dinner, golf tournaments and events for Heads of State.
Foley Family Wines & Spirits
In late 2024 Foley Family Wines & Spirits purchased Cosentino Wines through an auction in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court. In Napa Valley, Foley Wine Estates also owns Foley Johnson, Merus Estate, Kuleto Estate, Silverado Vineyards and the brand Swanson (but not the former winery). Previously, Foley Wine Estates operated Foley Food & Wine Society tasting room, which was located at the Vista Collina Resort, just south of the city of Napa, but closed in 2021.
Chairman, CEO, President and namesake for his company, Bill Foley II graduated from West Point in 1967 and later earned his law degree from the University of Washington in 1974. Foley has a background that reads like someone who has lived multiple lives; he is a graduate of West Point, has served in the Air Force and has both his MBA and law degrees. He has been Chairman of CKE (controls Carl’s Junior) where he helped turned that franchise around in part by appealing to younger generations. Currently he serves as Chairman of two Fortune 500 companies including Fidelity National Information Services, a major title company that is one of the largest in the nation. Also of note is his golfing ability; he was voted among the Top 20 Executive Golfers in Golfer’s Digest Magazine.
Long since invested in a diversity of businesses – wine is only one of his passions. He is also owner and founder of the Las Vegas Golden Knights National Hockey team. And in 2018 the team shocked the world of hockey fans by making it all the way to the Stanley Cup Finals in their first year. The team won the Stanley Cup in 2023.
Bill has enjoyed fine Cabernet Sauvignon for many years and his foray into the wine industry started in 1996 with the acquisition of Lincourt Vineyards in the Santa Ynez Valley (Santa Barbara County). He soon purchased several other wineries in the Central Coast region and over the years has acquired numerous properties in other parts of California, Oregon and Washington.
For more information or to join one of their wine clubs (choose either Mixed, Red Wines or a Custom Case), visit: www.cosentinowinery.com
ARCHIVED NOTES
In late 2010 Mitch sold the winery, accompanying vineyard and brand to current owners, Santa Rosa based Vintage Wine Estates (headquarters are in the Airport Business Center). Mitch stayed with the company for several years as a Brand Ambassador and consulting winemaker. Today he runs his own brand pureCru.
Vintage Wine Estates was founded in 2009 by prominent vintners including Pat Roney, Leslie Rudd (Rudd Winery), Michael Stewart (Stewart Cellars) and Chuck Sweeney (Vine Cliff Winery). In a rather short amount of time, Vintage Wine Estates has become a significant player in the wine worlds of Napa and Sonoma – with the acquisition of a number of winery properties and vineyards in both counties as well as elsewhere in California and out of state. In Napa, as of our latest update – in addition to Cosentino Winery, they own Clos Pegase, Delectus, Girard, Swanson and the former Napa based Cartlidge & Brown. The total brands and wineries under their ownership now totals more than 35.
Despite having a winery on site, this production facility is not used any more for the Cosentino wines, rather production shifted up to Clos Pegase Winery in Calistoga until the sale of the brand to Foley Family Wine Estates. The property is 4.5 acres of which about 2.5 acres are planted to vines directly behind the winery (Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot). The tracks for the Napa Valley Wine Train bisect a number of vineyards here and one can sometimes see the train passing through – (easiest to see in the winter when the vineyards have shed their leaves).
Cosentino was one of the first “roadside” located wineries visitors would see driving up Highway 29 from Napa – and as a result of this prime location they would often host first time visitors who are traveling to Napa Valley without any set itinerary. The tasting room was often busy in the mornings when people drive into the valley or later in the afternoon – as people enjoy making a stop here to finish the day. And refreshingly compared to most area wineries who close between 4 and 5pm, Cosentino would stay open daily until 6pm. Hosts tended to offer sizable pours and sometimes bring extra wines for guests to try.
This was the rare Napa Valley winery that offers cider for purchase. Vintage Wine Estates owns Ace Cider and a limited number of bottles are for sale in the tasting room.
In addition, the winery was directly next door to the well-liked Mustards Grill and diners often drift on over for a tasting if they have to wait for a table. Two small wooden bridges connect the two properties passing above a very tiny creek that is most often dry unless there has been substantial rain recently. And on the other side of the winery was The Amizetta Farmhouse, a handsome sizable country estate owned by the family that owns Amizetta Winery (the house and rooms can be rented out). Cosentino was also conveniently located near the southern of the two iconic Napa Valley welcome signs often a backdrop for tourists posing with their heads dramatically thrown back for selfies to make their Instagram followers jealous.
This winery was not what came to mind when one thinks of a Mediterranean old-world building; the exterior was covered with ivy and tall cypress trees grow nearby. The tasting room was simply decorated; several tasting options were offered including indoor or outdoor patio experiences. Select current release wines could be paired with local chocolates or small bites available from their snack menu. From May through September on the first Friday of every month between 4-6pm, their chef prepared small tapas plates which are paired with the wines. Often guests tasting outside would be treated to the tantalizing aromas of food wafting over from Mustards Grill.
Out of more than 1,200 unique Napa wineries, producers and tasting rooms visited to date, this was the only one that many years ago featured sliding spittoons on a rail built into their tasting counter. Need to spit, the host would grab hold of the spittoon cart and slide it down to you – ingenious!
Exterior
Interior
Leave a Reply