Sullivan Rutherford Estate

Sullivan Rutherford Estate, previously known as Sullivan Family Vineyards was founded by the late Jim Sullivan and his wife JoAnna. Jim was a graphic design artist in Los Angeles; his firm Sullivan Graphic Arts became a well-known firm in the city, working with several well prominent rock bands and others in the 1950s and 1960s including for the Monkees and Dick Clark Productions. His son Ross (who we have met) recalls his father planted a small backyard vineyard in 1959 when the family was living in Van Nuys – eventually his father made home wine while living in Los Angeles.

Both Jim and JoAnna came from California farming families; Jim’s relatives were (and still are) in Solvang and Santa Ynez (Central California) along with in Marysville (Central Valley) and JoAnna’s family farmed in Napa Valley (what is now the Oak Knoll District) until the early 1900s. Jim and JoAnna looked a various wine regions in California in the 1960s and then ultimately decided Napa Valley was where they wanted to move to realizing that dry wine was beginning to outsell sweet wines and red wine was becoming more popular among consumers.

They initially moved to Rutherford in 1972 purchasing a small property on Manley Lane, a few minutes south of their winery location. In 1978 they purchased property from Virgil and Alice (Acquistapace) Galleron. Their surname is the namesake for Galleron Road where Sullivan Rutherford Estate is located; as of our latest update in 2025, Alice still lives next to their property and is 102 years young.

Brothers Adolphe and Virgile originally came to Napa Valley in 1918 and owned and managed a 402-acre ranch in Rutherford. Virgile was married to Angele and had two sons, Paul (a World War II veteran and Virgil). The Galleron family roots are in the Haute Alpes region of France where they were sheep herders. Their ranch in Rutherford was also used for raising sheep as well as like other area ranches, growing a variety of agricultural crops including walnuts, prunes, peaches and grapes.

Their son, Virgil Galleron was instrumental in the operations of the Napa Valley Cooperative Winery and served as President of the organization for 30 years beginning in 1954. In 1934 a number of men related to the wine industry met several times at the Rutherford Grange Hall in Rutherford (including in late July) to discuss the formation of a cooperative and also secure a winery site to crush grapes later that same year. Another meeting was organized at prominent vintner, Charles Forni’s house, who incidentally 10 years later would play an instrumental role in starting the Napa Valley Vintners Association. It was at Forni’s house on August 6, 1934, that the Napa Valley Cooperative was founded (incidentally, prunes were Napa Valley’s most valuable crop at this time).

The organization was launched with only nine original members; a mention in the Napa Valley Register dated September 4, 1934, references 1.57 acres transferred in ownership from Calistoga Vineyard Co in Calistoga to the Napa Valley Wine Cooperative. Several sources including, Napa Wine, a History by Charles L Sullivan reference the Napa Valley Wine Cooperative used a historic structure near the corner of Grant and Stevenson Streets in Calistoga for that year’s harvest. An article in the Napa Journal dated February 17, 1935, indicates the Calistoga location (also known as the Petri Winery) crushed 3,137.5 tons in 1934. The next year (1935) their winery operations were moved to what is now site of Hall Winery, St. Helena, also at the time referred to as the Grier property or the Petri Winery. The group purchased this site in southern St. Helena and operated as the Napa Valley Cooperative for some 50+ years. It should be noted that Calistoga Vineyard Co was already operating out of this site, as they were making vinegar at the end of Prohibition here.

Starting in 1952 all the grapes processed at Napa Valley Cooperative Winery were sold to GALLO who marketed the resulting wines as their own. Virgil had joined the board of directors of the cooperative the previous year. The cooperative at one point was producing over a million cases of wine a year and at the height of its production was responsible for producing about 40% of all the Napa Valley wines. The deal with GALLO lasted for 34 years.

—

Ross grew up in Rutherford; he has a number of memories from his youth but one stands out; he recalls the iconic André Tchelistcheff driving up to their home in his blue Corvette from time to time asking his father for a light (Andre was a heavy smoker). Tchelistcheff also provided the Sullivan’s advice on which varieties to plant on their property.

Following in her father’s footsteps, Kelleen is well-known artist, creating mostly wine related pieces; some of her works were on display in the tasting room and her art has graced many labels of their wines over the years.

In late 2017 the winery was sold to the investment firm VITE USA Inc., based in Sausalito and led by the dynamic and personable Juan Pablo Torres-Padilla, Sullivan’s Managing Partner. Juan Pablo grew up in Mexico City with his first exposure to wine coming through his grandfather who drank wines from Bordeaux and Burgundy. Later in life, he moved to France for what was planned to be a short 6 months stay, but after meeting his future wife and settling down in Paris for work and family, he ended up staying in France for nearly 16 years. During his time in the country, he took full advantage of several wine regions – often visiting Bordeaux, Champagne and Burgundy and touring some of the great chateaus along with smaller lesser-known producers.

In 2006 on a trip to Burgundy with an uncle he found himself tasting in what might be considered one of the holy grails of wine tasting – a private tasting with Aubert de Villaine, the co-owner and co-director of the Domaine de la Romanee-Conti. During his visit, he and his uncle pondered the idea of someday owning vineyards and a winery. A number of years later they began looking for winery & vineyard property in Burgundy and then Bordeaux. Not finding what he wanted, Juan Pablo returned to the states and began visiting Napa Valley in 2016. He began actively searching for wineries for sale, estimating he visited over 100 Napa based wineries in his research and search for the right property. One of his wine advisers introduced him to Sullivan Vineyards and by late 2017 the sale of the estate and winery was complete.

Juan Pablo has been drawn to wine for a number of reasons, but he is always fascinated by how wine touches people from all walks of life – across social and economic status.

His vision with Sullivan Vineyards is to incrementally elevate their wine making program and hospitality while at the same time preserving the sense of place of this particular property and the Sullivan family’s rich history and contributions to the wine world.

Sullivan produced its first vintage in 1981; prior to this they were growing grapes for other wineries. Today the estate is 26 acres of which 22 are planted. Since the transition in ownership, two other non-Rutherford vineyard properties were acquired including a parcel off of Soda Canyon Road in the southern part of the valley and the 18-acre Criscione Vineyard in the hills east of St. Helena for a total of approximately 40 planted acres of grapes.

With a family pedigree of farming, the Sullivan’s have always paid careful attention to their vines – dry farming and also managing their vineyards in-house rather than hiring an outside vineyard management company.

For a small winery (about 5000 cases) they offer a wide selection of wines, including a Chardonnay (they no longer produce Sauvignon Blanc), although the focus of their production is on Bordeaux red varieties. Sullivan Rutherford Estate also holds back a certain number of older vintages; these library wines are selectively available.

The winery is located just minutes off the main busy “wine strip” of Highway 29 in the heart of Rutherford, a part of the valley sometimes described as the 50-yard line of the Napa Valley due to its central location. Their location makes it very easy to find yet at the same time seems as if you have landed in the middle of an oasis away from all the traffic and hustle and bustle of Highway 29. It is quiet here among the beautifully landscaped gardens with bucolic views overlooking the pond. The wine tasting room adjoins the barrel room and is located across a courtyard from the main residence (formerly where the Sullivan’s lived, it is now used for private events). The home and winery were designed by John Marsh Davis – known for his ‘organic’ style of architecture including Joseph Phelps Winery and Rutherford Hill Vineyards.

Select Wines
Whites/Rosé
The 2023 Sullivan Rosé Rutherford Estate, Rutherford Napa Valley is 100% varietal Merlot. This wine is pale to medium salmon in color; the bouquet is elegant and sophisticated, this latter adjective a word we rarely use in wine writing but one we sometimes reserve for rosé. Its scents are a union of mineralities, floral, citrus and lighter red fruits. These include raspberry, wild white strawberries, rose petals, hibiscus, ruby grapefruit, blood orange, pineapple guava, water being poured on warm slate rock and chalkboard. Bone dry, the palate delivers flavors of strawberry, cran-apple, raspberry, Rainier cherry, cranberry and pomegranate. Vibrant, but with a restrained energy, the palate offers a lightly creamy character, offset nicely by its bright acidity. A refreshing 13.2% ABV. Thoroughly enjoyable, this balanced beauty is one of Napa Valley’s more satisfying rosé’s. Needling and nosing this wine made us want to pair it with seafood – perhaps ahi tuna or BBQ shrimp.

The 2022 Sullivan Rutherford Estate Chardonnay, Napa Valley is medium to deep gold in color; the bouquet immediatley sports a honeyed character including of honeycomb with loads of further ripe fruits and dessert spices at play. Additional scents include butterscotch, creme Brule, vanilla, tapioca pudding, Graham cracker, hazelnut, baked golden apples, ripe Alphonso mango, ripe papaya and toast. This is a serious Chardonnay, delivering plenty of flavor and ripeness but it is also simultaneously light on its feet. This wine tastes like apricot, peaches in light syrup, yellow nectarine, baked apples and a lingering note of vanilla. Its texture is best described as being silky and satiny, like running ones hands across a soft cashmere sweater; this textural attribute is supported by a richly flavored long lasting finish and a balanced and bright acidity. Can we make a comparison to some of Aubert’s finer Chardonnays, perhaps his Sugar Shack bottling, also from a vineyard in Rutherford? We just did.

Coeur de Vigne
Legend has it that the borders of Rancho Caymus and Rancho Carne Humana (two of a number of early Ranchos located in the Napa Valley) were formed after a horse walking north from Napa and a horse walking south from the town of Calistoga met about half way between the two locations. In any case, the name of this wine, Coeur de Vigne means “heart of the vine” in French referencing their geographical center point in Napa Valley. This wine is always a Bordeaux style blend and is the wine one will most likely find in distribution.

The 2014 Sullivan “Coeur de Vigne” Red Wine Blend shows lively and youthful fruit-driven aromatics accompanied by notes of dark chocolate. Somewhat savory or meaty on the palate, this wine offers bright acidity and slightly chalky tannins that linger for quite some time. This is a very balanced expression from an overall vintage in Napa Valley that showed well upon release.

Merlot
The 2021 Sullivan Rutherford Estate Merlot, Rutherford Napa Valley is deep ruby and opaque; both sweet, ripe and dark fruited, the intense bouquet reveals scents of baked plums, cherry pie, boysenberry jam, blackberry compote, Persian mulberry with supporting layers of dark chocolate, cloves and nutmeg. The fruit smells like it was just harvested at the peak of ripeness, four years post vintage. This wine tastes like dark plum, black cherry, boysenberry, Pakistani mulberry and blackberry. The palate is a coupling of plushness often associated with this variety, but also with a noticeable and persistent texture expressed that one doesn’t always find in Napa Valley floor grown Merlots. The finish lingers with fully coating gravelly and slightly grainy tannins, roasted herbs, dried sage, a kiss of pepper and an earthy almost chalk-like characteristic. This wine offers plenty of depth and complexity and might be favored by Cabernet Sauvignon enthusiasts who often pass on lighter styled wines from this variety.

Cabernet Sauvignon
Sullivan’s flagship wine is the James O’Neil Sullivan Estate Cabernet Sauvignon. The 2013 James O’Neil Sullivan Estate Cabernet Sauvignon smells elegant and seductive at the same time; this is a bouquet that keeps evolving wonderfully given time with an intriguing depth of aroma. Shows dark fruit including plum and blackberry complemented nicely initially with more subtle aromas of vanilla and espresso and as it breathes milk chocolate. Supple upon the entry and throughout the palate, the wine has a seamless quality in its youth. The polished and well-integrated tannins feel good in the mouth – somewhat dusty, or chalky they linger softly but with great length on the finish. This wine features bright acidity and is somewhat savory on the palate with a hint of lingering tobacco smoke. This is one of the more intriguing Cabernet Sauvignon wines we have tried from Napa Valley this year (2018). This wine is named after the winery founder Jim O’Neil Sullivan, and the artist that created the image for the label; look closely at the label, you will see a woman’s face somewhat hidden at first glance.

Sullivan produces several wines under the J.O. Sullivan Founder’s Reserve label including Cabernet Sauvignon and a Merlot. Merlot does particularly well on their property; it has been growing on site since 1972 and was first produced in 1981.

NOTE: additional tasting notes needed and will be added as time and budget allow.

PA Vinea
In 2022 Sullivan Estate announced plans to build a new winery and hospitality center, overseen by Hans Baldauf of BCV Architecture + Interiors. Construction began in 2025 with plans to be completed sometime around mid summer 2026. This is part of the property’s transformation and new vision since the change in ownership. The winery building was designed by architect Hans Baldauf of BCV Architecture + Interiors and Orla Huq Regan of Orla Studios. Once construction is completed the property and winery will transition from Sullivan Rutherford Estate to PA Vinea. The first vintage under the new label was from 2019.

PA is the acronym for the Latin words, Proportion Aurea – referring to the Golden Ratio. The PA Vinea wines are produced in extremely limited quantities for club members. As a result of all these changes, this review has been identified as needing a *major* update. We will revisit once all the construction is completed, and the name change has been made.

Poetry Inn
Formerly known as the CrossRoads Inn (founded in the late 1980s) this luxurious 5-room boutique hotel re-branded and opened in 2005 as the Poetry Inn. It is the only accommodation along the Silverado Trail in the Stags Leap District and is perched on the hillsides directly above Cliff Lede’s Poetry Vineyard and is mere minutes from the tasting room. It was designed by the late Howard Backen.

NOTE: in August 2024, Clif Lede Winery sold Poetry Inn to PA Capital Management, the parent company of Sullivan Vineyards. While the inn was sold, Clif Lede did not sell their Poetry Vineyard.

Each room is named after a prominent poet including Emily Dickinson, Walt Whitman, Robert Frost, Robert Louis Stevenson and e.e Cummings – and each author’s books are available in their particular room. One settled in, guests can enjoy the seasonally heated pool and Jacuzzi, spa and use of the highly personalized concierge services. Each room features a wood-burning fireplace, a private balcony, and both indoor and outdoor showers. And guests enjoy a luxurious breakfast made by the Poetry Inn chef (in-room dining available).

We have visited the property several times; regardless of the time of year, the views are stunning of the valley floor below. Private west facing porches overlook the vineyards and are complemented with postcard like sunsets that slowly fall behind the Mayacamas mountains to the west.

In 2021 St. Helena based interior designer Erin Martin redesigned the interior of the guest rooms.

Loco Tequila
Juan Pablo is also Co-Founder and Managing Partner of an exciting Tequila project called Loco Tequila, founded in 2012. The company is restoring Hacienda de La Providencia in the tiny community of El Arenal, Jalisco (about a 30-minute drive from Tequila). The hacienda dates from the 18th century and was abandoned in the 1960s; it was added as a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 2006. It will house tasting rooms, a tequila museum, a cave, a hotel and several event spaces. A distillery is also being added to the property. Their Tequila is sourced entirely from agave plants growing in El Arenal, Jalisco and is crafted using historical production methods. Tequila Loco owns 200 acres of agave plantations.

We will visit this property in the coming years and will update our notes here after our visit. Visit the hacienda’s website here: www.haciendalaprovidencia.com

—

Over the decades, Sullivan has won numerous awards for the quality of their wines and in the early 1990s was voted as one of the top wineries in the world by The Wine Spectator. More recently they were listed among wine writer James Suckling’s Top 100 Red Wines. And speaking of James Suckling, visitors to Hong Kong should check out his James Suckling Wine Central wine bar & restaurant on the second floor of the Staunton Hotel on Hong Kong Island. Visitors are greeted with a splash at their table or at the bar of wine – always a bottle rated 90 points or higher by Suckling. The wine list totals some 600 unique bottles. And the culinary scene is also one of the highlights here; during our visit we enjoyed our first proper salad in 3 months following our extended stay in Thailand.

The vast majority of their wines are sold directly through the tasting room or their wine clubs. A tasting is always relaxed, down to earth, private and geared to your wine interests. All visits are by appointment.

For more information and to join their membership list, visit: www.sullivanwine.com